Imagine finding a home that feels like a story waiting to be told, nestled in settings that blend natural beauty with vibrant community life. From a historic 1845 Victorian in Newfield near Ithaca’s cultural allure to a fully renovated retreat by Clayton’s waterfront, these four properties across New York State captivate with unique character and charm. Each offers versatility—be it a primary residence, seasonal getaway, or investment venture—while promising comfort with modern updates and outdoor spaces. Priced between $295,000 and $365,000, they invite you to explore a life connected to nature and local treasures.
Historical Victorian Gem | $365,000


Ivan ‘Z’ Newell

Ivan ‘Z’ Newell
Set against the serene backdrop of rural New York, this captivating 1845 Victorian home embodies timeless charm and authentic 19th-century craftsmanship. Steeped in character, it showcases rare original details such as unpainted woodwork, wide plank wood floors, custom built-ins, and distinctive “butterfly corner block” moldings. Every corner of this residence radiates warmth and personality, offering a unique glimpse into a bygone era. Ideally suited for a Bed & Breakfast, Airbnb venture, or a cherished private retreat, the property enjoys a prime location just five minutes from the scenic Buttermilk Falls and Robert H. Treman State Parks. With downtown Ithaca less than ten minutes away and Cornell University a short 15-minute drive, convenience blends seamlessly with countryside tranquility. Living here places you in the heart of a region celebrated by CNN Travel as America’s best town to visit in 2025.
- Price:
- $365,000
- Size:
- 2,068 sq ft
- Contact:
- Ivan ‘Z’ Newell, Ithaca Home At Last, 607.677.6700
17079 May Irwin Rd | $349,900


Tina Zwetsch

Tina Zwetsch
Perched atop an elevated mountain setting, this newly renovated residence offers a seamless blend of modern comfort and serene surroundings. Step inside to discover a bright living room anchored by a cozy gas fireplace, ideal for unwinding on crisp evenings. Fresh finishes, luxury resilient flooring, and updated electrical systems flow throughout, complemented by a new 30-year architectural roof and high-efficiency furnace with central air. The spacious eat-in kitchen, complete with a morning room and formal dining area, invites gatherings of all kinds. Three generous bedrooms and a pristine bathroom provide ample space, while a practical mudroom with first-floor laundry adds convenience. Outside, an oversized covered patio with built-in lighting creates a perfect retreat for morning coffee or evening relaxation. Just minutes from the marina, local dining, and Clayton Village, this home effortlessly balances tranquility with accessibility.
- Price:
- $349,900
- Size:
- 1,344 sq ft
- Contact:
- Tina Zwetsch, Blue Arrow Real Estate, 585.820.2242
Your Dream Home | $329,900


Tara Vancauwenberge

Tara Vancauwenberge
Situated in the serene Ilion neighborhood, Applewood Drive offers a rare opportunity to embrace the charm of the Fall season. This inviting residence backs onto a picturesque golf course, where you can unwind on a modern Trex deck while soaking in tranquil views of surrounding trees. With two separate blacktopped driveways, parking is never an issue, and one leads to a spacious garage perfect for vehicles, storage, or hobbies. Inside, the expansive open layout awaits your personal touch, complemented by the ease of first-floor living with a bedroom, full bath, and laundry all conveniently located on the main level. Additional perks include access to municipal power for guilt-free heating during winter months, low taxes, and proximity to local snowmobile trails. This property seamlessly blends comfort and convenience, creating an ideal setting for a relaxed lifestyle.
- Price:
- $329,900
- Size:
- 1,500 sq ft
- Contact:
- Tara Vancauwenberge, Coldwell Banker Faith Properties, 315.868.9394
15090 Walmer St | $295,000


Gina Bahamonde

Gina Bahamonde
Tucked away in the serene embrace of a picturesque valley, this charming ranch home offers a peaceful retreat from the everyday hustle. Spanning 1,092 square feet, the property features two cozy bedrooms and a full bathroom, complemented by an attached one-car garage. Set within the esteemed Blue Valley School District, it promises an enviable location for families seeking quality education. The home is surrounded by expansive front and back yards, where endless possibilities await for outdoor gatherings or quiet evenings under the stars. With its inherent potential for remodeling or rehabilitation, this residence invites creativity and vision to transform it into a personalized haven. Whether you’re dreaming of a countryside escape or a unique project, this hidden gem in a coveted zip code provides the perfect canvas to craft a life of tranquility and fulfillment.
- Price:
- $295,000
- Size:
- 1,092 sq ft
- Contact:
- Gina Bahamonde, Platinum Realty LLC, 816.522.9859

















