A Storybook Victorian with Modern Possibilities in Caldwell

September 11, 20261 min read

Set in the heart of Caldwell, this distinctive Victorian residence offers a rare blend of historic character, generous space, and modern versatility. Dating to 1900, the home sits on a spacious lot surrounded by mature landscaping, creating a peaceful setting with plenty of room to enjoy the outdoors. Original architectural details and inviting interiors bring timeless charm to everyday living, while a separate studio, carriage house, and workshop add space for work, hobbies, guests, or creative pursuits. With its storybook character and flexible spaces, this Caldwell property offers a unique opportunity to embrace historic living with modern possibilities.

3904 S Indiana Avenue | $529,900

3904 S Indiana Avenue, Caldwell, ID 83605

LISTING AGENT:
Listing agents: Rachel Johnson

More than just a home, this is a distinctive property with character, space and room to dream. Set on approx. .58 acre, this beautifully cared-for 1900 Victorian offers timeless charm, beautiful historic details and a warm, inviting feel, along with enjoyable outdoor space and bonus areas that invite you to think beyond the typical home. A finished 14×24 heated/cooled studio is ideal for an office, creative studio, gym, music room or hobby space, while the original 12×18 carriage house/workshop with power, large 2+ car covered area with storage/covered patio and unfinished basement add function and flexibility. Mature grounds offer extra parking, room to garden, gather, work on projects or simply enjoy more breathing room. No HOA adds flexibility. City water, Pioneer irrigation and additional utility improvements already on site add versatility. An ADU, expanded shop, multigenerational space, home-based business, intimate gathering/venue concept or other uses may offer even more possibilities for the right buyer to explore and verify with applicable city/county agencies. Brothers Park is directly across the street, home to Caldwell’s 4th of July fireworks, with the YMCA next door. Storybook charm, timeless architecture, a generous setting, convenient Caldwell location, and endless ways to make it your own all come together in one truly special property.