Explore These Exclusive Communities in the Finger Lakes Region

Ithaca | Christopher Chan

Discover some of the most exclusive communities in the Finger Lakes region of New York. 

Skaneateles

Skaneateles is renowned as one of the most prestigious areas in the Finger Lakes region. Known for its crystal-clear lake, upscale boutiques, and gourmet restaurants, this neighborhood offers an unparalleled living experience. The vibrant downtown area features exquisite shops, art galleries, and a range of fine dining options. According to Redfin data from May, the real estate market is moderately competitive, with a median home sale price of $1.45 million, and the average homes went pending in around 34 days.

Aurora

Aurora is a charming village on the eastern shore of Cayuga Lake, known for its historical significance and upscale living. Home to the prestigious Wells College, Aurora boasts elegant architecture, boutique shops, and fine dining establishments. The real estate market is exclusive, with beautifully restored historic homes and lakefront properties that command high prices, often between $400,000 to $800,000.  

Canandaigua

Boasting botanical gardens, artisanal breweries, and a bustling farmers market, Canandaigua is a beacon of luxury in the Finger Lakes region. The downtown area, highlighted by Historic Main Street, offers indie boutiques, art galleries, and top-tier restaurants along pedestrian-friendly streets. Canandaigua is currently exhibiting a seller’s market, making it highly competitive. In June, the median home sale price was $355,000, with 33.3% of homes selling above the initial asking rate, according to Redfin.

Ithaca

Ithaca, a vibrant and culturally rich city, is home to several exclusive neighborhoods, particularly near Cornell University and Ithaca College. Known for its stunning gorges, waterfalls, and lush landscapes, Ithaca offers a perfect blend of natural beauty and urban sophistication. The downtown area, known as the Ithaca Commons, features high-end boutiques, gourmet restaurants, and a thriving arts scene. Real estate in Ithaca is moderately competitive, with a median sale price around $384,000 in May, per Redfin. Homes in prestigious neighborhoods, especially those with views of Cayuga Lake or proximity to the universities, often command higher prices and sell quickly.

Cayuga Heights

Rated as one of New York’s best places to live by Niche, Cayuga Heights is synonymous with luxury and elegance. This neighborhood is home to beautiful parks, cozy cafes and restaurants, and a serene nature preserve. Corners Community is a focal point for upscale shopping, salons, and more. The real estate market is fairly competitive, with a median home sale price of $650,000 reported by Redfin in May. Properties typically entered pending status within 36 to 54 days, reflecting the area’s desirability.