The Catskills region has emerged as one of New York’s most sought-after destinations for mountain home buyers, particularly as we move through the second half of 2025. The region continues to attract buyers seeking both natural beauty and investment potential. Based on current real estate trends and market analysis, three locations stand out as premier destinations for mountain home purchases this year.
SUBSCRIBE TO THE HAVEN MAILING LIST
Curated homes, market intelligence and design stories — a few emails a month.
No spam. Unsubscribe any time.
Hunter Mountain Area: The Premium Alpine Experience
Hunter Mountain remains the crown jewel of Catskills real estate, offering access to year-round outdoor recreation and stunning mountain vistas. The area surrounding Hunter has seen consistent demand from buyers seeking luxury mountain retreats, with properties featuring ski-in, ski-out access commanding premium prices. Current market trends show strong appreciation in this region, driven by its established infrastructure and proximity to both winter sports facilities and summer hiking trails.
The Hunter area appeals particularly to buyers from New York City and the tri-state region who value the two-hour drive time and well-developed amenities. Properties here typically feature larger lot sizes, with many homes showcasing contemporary mountain architecture that maximizes views of the surrounding peaks. According to Realtor.com data, the median listing home price in Hunter was $409K in July, trending up 12.3% year-over-year. The rental potential for vacation properties in this area remains robust, making it attractive for investment-minded buyers.
Catskill and Athens: Historic Charm Meets Modern Convenience
The towns of Catskill and Athens have gained significant traction among mountain home buyers seeking a blend of historic character and modern amenities. These Hudson River communities offer excellent value propositions while still providing easy access to mountain recreation areas. The revitalized downtowns feature art galleries, farm-to-table restaurants, and cultural venues that appeal to sophisticated buyers.
What sets this area apart is the combination of waterfront and mountain access, with many properties offering views of both the Hudson River and the Catskill peaks. The real estate market here has shown steady growth, with buyers appreciating the walkable downtown areas and the availability of larger parcels of land just minutes from town centers. The area’s growing reputation as an arts destination has also contributed to property value appreciation.
Recent infrastructure improvements and the influx of creative professionals working remotely have strengthened the local economy, making this region particularly attractive for year-round residents rather than just seasonal buyers. Properties range from restored Victorian homes in town to contemporary builds on hillside lots with panoramic mountain views.
Livingston Manor: The Emerging Hotspot
This Sullivan County community offers exceptional value for mountain home buyers, with significantly lower entry prices than more established Catskills destinations while still providing access to pristine wilderness areas and trout fishing streams.
The area has benefited from increased attention following the development of boutique hospitality venues and farm-to-table dining establishments. Young professionals and creative types have discovered Livingston Manor as an affordable alternative to pricier Catskills locations, driving demand and property values upward. The town’s proximity to the Willowemoc Creek and Beaverkill River makes it particularly appealing to outdoor enthusiasts.
Properties in Livingston Manor often feature larger acreage at more accessible price points, making it ideal for buyers seeking privacy and space for outdoor activities.
Market Outlook for Mountain Home Buyers
The Catskills mountain home market shows signs of stabilization, though conditions vary across towns. While broader inventory appears to be growing slightly after years of scarcity, competition remains fierce for homes offering exceptional views, acreage, or distinctive design. Towns like Athens and Livingston Manor are currently experiencing buyer-favorable dynamics, whereas select areas—such as Catskill—continue to capture premium prices despite slower turnover. The enduring influence of remote work keeps demand strong among urban professionals and second-home seekers, ensuring that the Catskills remain an attractive and resilient mountain living destination.
